Priscilla Presley scored a partial victory in her bitter $50 million legal war with her former business advisers Monday, persuading a judge to toss out four of the 21 claims filed against her in a fraud and breach of contract lawsuit.
But Presley failed to persuade the judge to spike lengthy paragraphs from the lawsuit concerning her divorce from Elvis Presley and the shocking 2023 death of their daughter, Lisa Marie Presley. The judge blasted some of the “extremely long” complaint as “gratuitous and mean-spirited” but said striking the disputed language would make little difference because the claims were already public.
The new ruling issued Monday dismissed claims that Presley interfered with a cosmetics contract and improperly used her own name, image, and likeness in violation of an alleged agreement with business advisers Brigitte Kruse and Kevin Fialko. Ruling from the bench, Los Angeles County Judge Mark Epstein said the allegations were not sufficiently supported by facts in the complaint. Though she won on four causes of action, Presley lost her bid to toss out 10 other claims related to fraud, breach of contract, and the alleged misappropriation of funds allegedly belonging to companies she purportedly set up with Kruse and Fialko.
Among the allegations Presley sought to remove from the lawsuit were claims that her “thirst for power and money was insatiable” during her divorce from Elvis Presley and that she prematurely “pulled the plug” on their daughter, Lisa Marie Presley, for financial gain. Lisa Marie died in 2023 after being hospitalised with a small bowel obstruction linked to a prior bariatric surgery. (In her memoir, Softly, As I Leave You: Life After Elvis, Presley wrote that Lisa Marie went into cardiac arrest at the hospital and was resuscitated, but then doctors told her she had “little brain activity” and would have “no quality of life” if kept on life support.)
Monday’s hearing came three years after Presley’s legal battle with Kruse and Fialko first reached the courts. Kruse, a prominent memorabilia dealer, filed the initial legal action in Florida in October 2023, accusing Presley of abandoning the series of companies they formed to capitalise on her name, image, and likeness.
Presley filed a separate lawsuit in Los Angeles in July 2024, accusing Kruse and Fialko of elder abuse. She described Kruse as a “con artist and pathological liar” who had misappropriated more than $1 million and fraudulently induced her to sign agreements giving the pair an 80 percent stake in some of her business ventures. Kruse and Fialko subsequently moved their claims from Florida to California, filing a $50 million cross-complaint last year.
In video exclusively obtained by Rolling Stone, Presley is seen signing the contracts behind her deals with Kruse and Fialko. In the ensuing legal battle, Kruse has claimed Presley was facing “impending financial ruin” when Kruse and Fialko stepped in to help rescue the cultural icon. Kruse alleges Presley then cut her out because her financial circumstances changed dramatically in the wake of Lisa Marie Presley’s death. As Rolling Stone previously reported, two weeks after Lisa Marie died on Jan. 12, 2023, Presley challenged a 2016 amendment to her daughter’s trust that removed her as a co-trustee. Presley later reached a settlement with granddaughter Riley Keough that granted her a $1 million lump-sum payment, a $100,000 annual salary, and burial rights near Elvis at Graceland.
Love Music?
Get your daily dose of everything happening in Australian/New Zealand music and globally.
On Monday, Judge Epstein gave Kruse and Fialko an opportunity to amend their complaint and revive some of the dismissed claims under different legal theories, potentially including breach of contract. But he cautioned against expanding on the background paragraphs Presley challenged as “inflammatory.”
“If you want to cut out some of the stuff written for a different audience, I wouldn’t shed any tears,” Epstein said.
The judge also expressed frustration with the pace of the litigation. When the lawyer for Kruse and Fialko suggested they might seek to add Authentic Brands Group as a defendant, Epstein urged him to act promptly. Authentic Brands acquired certain commercial rights to the Presley name in 2013 through its purchase of Elvis Presley’s licensing business. Priscilla Presley had sold those rights to a predecessor company in 2005, a transaction Kruse and Fialko allege she concealed from them.
“My goal is to get this done. If there’s a third party to sue, sue them,” Judge Epstein said. “This case is getting really long in the tooth.”
After the hearing, a lawyer for Kruse and Fialko characterised the ruling as a victory.
“We are pleased with the court’s ruling today, which denied Priscilla Presley’s motion to strike, in full, and which denied her attempt to dismiss our clients’ claims of fraud against her,” Jordan Matthews of Holtz Matthews LLP said in a statement to Rolling Stone. “We intend to vigorously enforce our clients’ rights.”
Lawyers for Presley did not immediately respond to a request for comment.
From Rolling Stone US


