75 Greatest Boy Band Songs of All Time

Six years after splitting up, the Jonas Brothers released their fifth full-length album, Happiness Begins, and redefined what it meant to be a freshly reunited boy band. Prior to their latest run, boy band reunions based around the release of new music weren’t usually guarantees for success. The magic formula for these specific types of bubblegum pop vocal trios relies on their youthful charm and charisma; songs about marriage and fatherhood don’t typically cut it in the same way. With “Sucker,” the Jonas Brothers proved that idea very wrong. In fact, the former Disney trio were able to perfectly mesh nostalgia with a huge new musical step that brought them their biggest single yet. “Sucker” pays tribute to the boys’ partners, all of whom they are now married to. Aided by pop savant Ryan Tedder, the catchy, guitar-driven banger is sexier than anything the boys would have attempted back during their early days, and the pay-off has been crystal clear.

The earliest days of the MTV era were also a golden age for reggae-tinged pop — The Police’s “Every Little Thing She Does Is Magic,” Blondie’s “The Tide Is High” and Stevie Wonder’s “Master Blaster (Jammin’)” were but a few of the island-inspired tracks staking out spots on radio. In 1982, the British five-piece Musical Youth hit it big with “Pass the Dutchie,” a cleaned-up version of the roots-reggae trio Mighty Diamonds’ “Pass the Koutchie.” For a more kiddie-friendly feel, the titular item being passed was changed from a pipe full of pot to a pot full of food. Rich vocal harmonies and an easily mimicked chorus helped it float to Number 10 on the Billboard Hot 100 in 1983, while its Don Letts-directed video was one of the first clips by black artists to get MTV airplay.

Harlem prodigy Frankie Lymon may have been just 13 years old when he co-wrote “Why Do Fools Fall in Love,” but he had already lived a lifetime of heartbreak. “I’ve been falling in love since I was only five,” he informed Frankie Laine in 1956. “But I’ve been a fool about it since I was 11.” The song was one of the earliest hits of the rock & roll era, remembered for its iconic oh wah opening and subsequent covers by everyone from the Beach Boys to Diana Ross. And with their matching outfits, tight harmonies, and screaming female fans, the Teenagers set the tone for every boy band that followed in their wake. Sadly, Lymon died of a heroin overdose in 1968. He was just 25.

The Jackson 5 finished recording their debut album, Diana Ross Presents the Jackson 5, in August of 1969. Before the month was over they were already back in the studio: Lead single “I Want You Back” seemed like a sure thing and Berry Gordy needed a follow-up ready. Hence “ABC,” the sound-alike single that would knock the Beatles’ “Let It Be” off the top of the charts less than seven months later. For a preteen Michael Jackson, it was a thrill just to watch songwriting team the Corporation come up with parts of the tune — the old-school “shake it, shake it, baby” bit, for instance — on the spot. “I loved ‘ABC’ from the first moment I heard it,’” he said. “I had more enthusiasm for that than I did for ‘I Want You Back.’”

This 1967 single from the Monkees, all tinkling piano and swelling woodwinds, served as the TV-borne foursome’s final chart-topper. Written by former Kingston Trio member John Stewart and featuring orchestration by trumpeter and arranger Shorty Rogers, the Davy Jones-crooned “Believer” is one of the band’s most luscious tunes. It received a second life during the reunion of Jones, Micky Dolenz and Peter Tork in 1986, with a remix serving as the B-side to comeback single “That Was Then, This Is Now.”

The Max Martin-helmed “Everybody (Backstreet’s Back)” was one of the most defining tracks of the late Nineties pop explosion — huge, produced like a Michael Bay movie and a little more PG-13 than the New Kids were — a perfect statement of intent for a group (and movement) ready for total world domination. With “Everybody”‘s campy, horror-themed video and dirty synth crunch, BSB not only became the new princes of pop but also the culture’s new sex symbols. “Am I sexual?” youngest member Nick Carter coyly asks.

Of course boy bands can be poignant, but it’s rare to get to see them flex with lyrics that go beyond romantic musings and heartbreak reflections. With “Spring Day,” BTS challenged that perception by analyzing grief and yearning in the form of a sweeping power ballad. The tender track is packed full of snow-y imagery (including a reference to Bong Joon-ho’s Snowpiercer) and painfully real lyrics about loss and grief, in whatever form that may take. You know it all/You’re my best friend/The sun will rise again,” the boys sing. “No darkness, no season/Can last forever.” A sentiment as timeless as BTS have become.

“Story of My Life” changed the musical course of this glossy X-Factor crew. Their third album, 2013’s Midnight Memories, saw the boys not only co-writing their songs but exploring Def Leppard-style hair metal, Big Star-esque power pop and Mumford & Sons-infused folk rock. “Story of My Life” was the clear star, featuring an adult-pop guitar riff and soaring vocals from matured members who found a way to gracefully enter adulthood together. “The demo that we played the boys sounds a lot more folk-y than it does now,” co-writer Jamie Scott told MTV. “That’s what amazing about their voices — straight away it sounds like them.”

Perhaps not as memorable or as danceable as other ‘N Sync hits, “It’s Gonna Be Me” nevertheless benefited from perfect timing. Released shortly after the start of ‘N Sync’s phenomenally successful No Strings Attached tour, it remains the group’s sole Hot 100 topping single. Written by Swedish hit-makers Max Martin, Andreas Carlsson and Rami Yacoub, the lyric juxtaposes the hesitancy of the song’s love interest with the determination of an eager-to-please beau represented by both JC Chasez and Justin Timberlake. The drama was played to surreal effect in the song’s video, helmed by veteran director Wayne Isham, who cast the boys as living dolls. “It’s the biggest thing I’ve ever worked on,” he told MTV. “That’s what the guys wanted. They wanted something with size, scope, scale and fun. … I couldn’t wait to … see their faces when they climbed up this 40-foot ramp of neon, up to this 35-foot-high sculpted stage that they’re on top of.” ‘N Sync would never be bigger.

When the Boyz II Men quartet came on the scene with 1991’s Cooleyhighharmony, they presented themselves as a slick, modern version of Motown doo-wop groups, combining dapper outfits and charm with the sound of Philly soul and new jack swing. Unlike the white-centric groups that would follow later in the decade, Boyz II Men didn’t hesitate to put their origins front and center, and the unabashed hometown pride of “Motownphilly” is what sets it apart from other “boy band” hits. The single gained an unexpected second life when it appeared on a 2013 episode of It’s Always Sunny in Philadelphia, where The Gang performs the hit song as part of a contest to open for Boyz II Men.

In 1995, a simple tale of kitchen-sink heartbreak was enough to elevate Take That from U.K. teenage obsession to national treasures to international stars. With the boys smartened up in Versace suits for the single cover, “Back For Good” signified a new maturity for the band, which disappointed those fond of TT’s campier disco origins — the NME called it “just too classy.” It’s doubtful Take That’s 2006 comeback would have been quite as successful without “Back For Good” having laid the groundwork, preparing adolescent fans to become a grown-up pop audience. Having finally proven his songwriting chops, Gary Barlow later boasted to have written “Back For Good” in less than 15 minutes. “The songs I write quickest seem to come out the best,” he told biographer Justin Lewis. Now firmly part of the British songbook, even the drunkest of traffic-cone-wearing rugby players could wipe a tear from their eye and bellow out “Whatever I said, whatever I did — I didn’t mean it!”

“Sherlock” isn’t an entirely original song, but instead the combination of two separate tracks by Korean quintet SHINee. Mashing up two cuts off the band’s 2012 Sherlock EP — the bouncy hip-hopper “Clue” and the impressive vocal track “Note” — “Sherlock” was touted as Korea’s first “hybrid remix” single. As an already beloved, already chart-topping boy band under Korea’s biggest music label, SM Entertainment, the Jackson 5-recalling tune shows how innovative and experimental K-pop can get, even for its most mainstream acts.

“‘I’ll Be There’ was our real breakthrough song,” Michael Jackson, who didn’t know what a harpsichord was until he heard the track’s demo, wrote in his memoir. “It was the one that said, ‘We’re here to stay.’” On the ballad, the young singer gives the most astounding performance of his preteens, skating and yelping and handing things off to older brother Jermaine. Recorded in the summer of 1970, “I’ll Be There” went to Number One by early fall, becoming not just the Jackson 5’s fourth chart-topper of the year but Motown’s then all-time best-seller.

“Hugs are overrated, just F.Y.I.,” Nick Jonas croons on “S.O.S.” after giving his ex-beau a high-five. The JoBros were as innocent as a pop group could get — like Osmonds-level innocent — grousing about conversations over instant message and text. However, the Disney-friendly, chaste Jonas Brothers were masters of a catchy pop-rock tune and toyed with rock authenticity long before One Direction famously began doing so with their third and fourth albums. Even though their time as a band of brothers has ended, solo careers for Nick and Joe Jonas have proved that their brief pop domination was in no way a fluke.

In the early Nineties, New Edition might have been officially broken up, but they were still the most-influential group in pop music. Case in point: Hi-Five, who blew up in 1991 with the Number One smash “I Like the Way (The Kissing Game).” The Waco, Texas group was the South’s answer to New Edition, with 15-year-old Tony Thompson crooning way up high in the style of Ralph Tresvant. Their next Top Ten hit, the slow jam “I Can’t Wait Another Minute,” was every bit as irresistible. Hi-Five had a crazy hot streak of hits for a couple of years: “Just Another Girlfriend,” “I Just Can’t Handle It,” “She’s Playing Hard to Get.” Their debut album also had an early rap from a very young Prodigy of Mobb Deep. Sadly, their later story is full of tragedy; Tony Thompson died of an overdose in 2007, at only 31.

One of the biggest boy band accidents occurred with the massive success of “Summer Girls” by LFO, a.k.a. Lyte Funkie Ones. The song sounds like an Adam Sandler parody of pop hits: a bunch of nonsensical phrases strung together with only Abercrombie & Fitch as its through-line. “‘Summer Girls’ was all about a summer on the cape,” now-deceased member Rich Cronin revealed of the song’s origins back in 2005. “Inside jokes. I never thought that anyone besides my close friends would ever hear it.” The silly single hit the Top 10 on the Billboard charts and led their debut album to double-platinum status. Though they didn’t get the chance to “have a bunch of hits” like New Kids on the Block, “Summer Girls” is still one of the quirkiest flukes in the genre’s history.